GOD ONLINE: Exploring media spirituality

Web sites, TV, films, books and the search for meaning.

Archive for the ‘jews’ Category

Movie review: ‘Replicas’ ignores the questions it raises

leave a comment »

Keanu Reeves explores a hologram of a brain in the new movie ‘Replicas.’

Are you a soul? Or just a collection of chemicals? Or maybe a mere matrix of memories?

What great questions for a science fiction movie. And Replicas uses software, robotics and cloning to explore them.

Unfortunately, it soon deserts them for mindless gunfire and car chases.

Will Foster works for a shadowy biotech company trying to transfer people’s minds into metal androids. Their ghoulish method involves grabbing dead accident victims and downloading their thought patterns, then uploading them into an android’s brain. (The process is kept vague, since it’s currently impossible.) Each effort ends in disaster, with the human/android freaking and tearing itself apart.

Will’s wife, Mona, raises the Big Questions surprisingly early in the film. He insists that despite the failures, it’s theoretically possible to bring someone back from the dead; it’s just a matter of memory and neurochemicals. She asks if he’s accounted for the possibility of the soul.

“That’s all I am — just pathways, electrical signals and chemistry?” she asks. “You have kids that love you and a wife that adores you — and we have a scientist.”

And the question doesn’t remain academic, not after Mona and the three children die in a car crash. Will somehow keeps his head enough to “record” the family’s minds just after their deaths. Then he prevails on a fellow lab worker to set up a biotech lab in his garage, using computers and chemical vats stolen from the company. (Never mind that until then, the focus was mechanical bodies.)

They manage to grow new bodies for the wife and kids, then transfer their thoughts and personalities into them. Are they the real family, or just clever copies? Well, the kids seem rather normal, but Mona acts rather distant, spooky, with slowed speech and distant stares. Reminds me of Scarlett Johansson in the 2014 film Lucy.

But no matter: Will’s CEO finds him out, musters some black-suited, gun-toting thugs and demands to know how he’s accomplished the feat that has been eluding the firm. From there, the story mutates into the cinematic cliché of the Big Evil Corporation That Will Stop at Nothing.

The movie at least has the virtue of having Will go to these insane lengths out of love for his family. That sets Replicas apart from stories like Frankenstein, where the mad scientist simply wants to play God. But it suffers from the casting of the main character: Keanu Reeves, whose emotional range is better suited to his cold-blooded John Wick character.

The main flaw, though, is how the film ignores the big questions it presents.

Ethics of cloning have long been discussed. If you copy yourself, is the clone another “you,” or does it have its own identity? Does it have the same rights as a naturally born human, or is it the property of the lab that produced it?

In Replicas, the question is leveled up: If you clone your mate and your children, are they really the same people you loved and lost? Or are they counterfeits?

And what if it’s possible to overlay some mechanical brain with your memories, thought patterns, vocabulary, etc.? Will your “self,” your consciousness, migrate there? Will it become you?

In online discussions, I’ve argued for a “No.” A clone may seem like the real thing to everyone else, even his or her loved ones. But one person will know the difference: you. If your alleged essence is uploaded to another body, everyone will act toward that replica as if it were you, even though the real you will have passed. That would become a kind of second death, I believe: to have died without anyone noticing.

The world’s religions have long dealt with matters of identity. The answer from Judaism and Christianity is that we are made in the image of God — B’tselem Elohim in Hebrew, Imago Dei in Latin. Islam tells a different story, of a pre-existent Adam in heaven, but still points to the deity as the origin of the self. All three religions therefore state that humans have souls independent of chemicals and “neural pathways.”

Is it empirical science? No. But c’mon, neither are the ideas in Replicas — notions of minds as software and the migration of consciousness. The movie could have at least given a bit more time to these beliefs of most people on Earth. They might have stayed with us longer than the violence that the filmmakers thought was so important.

— Jim Davis


Written by Jim Davis

January 15, 2019 at 5:28 am

Holiday Almanac: Sukkot recalls dependence on God

leave a comment »

aIsfahan_synagogue full size (2)

Torah scroll at Mullah Jacub’s Synagogue, Isfahan, Iran. Photographed by Hamed Saber via Wikimedia Commons (CC-By-2.0).

The somber High Holy Days, which ended on Sept. 19, give way today to Sukkot, the colorful Feast of Tabernacles. One of the three “Pilgrim Festivals” — the others are Passover and Shavuot — Sukkot recalls the Israelites’ travels in the Sinai desert after their liberation from slavery in Egypt.

The eight-day festival takes its name from the sukkah, a hut made by many Jewish families and synagogues. Loosely thatched and crudely built, the sukkah reminds Jews of their wandering ancestors’ meager shelters.

Fruits and flowers are hung from the sukkah rafters, recalling the other theme of the festival: gratitude to God for the fall harvest in the Holy Land, for which Israelis still celebrate it. Each morning of Sukkot, traditional Jews recite a blessing while holding four kinds of Israeli plants — a lulav or palm frond, an etrog or citron fruit, and branches of myrtle and willow.

Sukkot has been called the Jewish Thanksgiving and may even have been its model. The American Pilgrims were avid students of the Hebrew Scriptures, even comparing their crossing of the Atlantic to the Israelite crossing of the Red Sea. The Pilgrims, too, may well have adapted Sukkot to the New World.

The seventh day of Sukkot is Hoshana Rabba, or Great Help. In traditional synagogues on this day, members of the congregation carry the lulav and etrog in a procession of seven circuits, singing prayers for salvation. Some Jews call this day the “little Yom Kippur,” one more chance to gain God’s favor.

The last day of Sukkot is Shemini Atzeret, the Eighth Day of Solemn Assembly. It is a time to pray for rain in the Holy Land to assure good crops. It is also one of four times during the year for Yizkor memorial prayers honoring the dead.

Yet another event is sometimes celebrated on the same day in South Florida temples: Simhat Torah, the jubilant Rejoicing Over the Law. On Simhat Torah, the last lines are read from the giant pulpit Torah scroll in each synagogue. Then the scroll is rewound for another annual cycle of readings — and the rabbi carries it in procession around the synagogue, amid singing and dancing.

— Jim Davis

Written by Jim Davis

September 24, 2018 at 11:19 pm

A fresh start: Yom Kippur starts tonight for Jews

leave a comment »

Yom Kippur, the awesome Day of Atonement for Jews, finishes the High Holy Days starting at sundown today (Sept. 18). The holy days began at sundown Sept. 9 with Rosh Hashana, the Jewish new year.

The holy days are a time to examine one’s life, repent of shortcomings and resolve to correct them. Tradition says that God holds people’s lives in the balance during these “10 Days of Repentance” before determining their fate for the coming year.

Tonight’s service features the Kol Nidre, a prayer set to sad medieval music. The prayer pleads for release from “all vows” — the translation of Kol Nidre — to God that have not been kept.

All day tomorrow, the faithful will fast and attend a succession of synagogue services, including Yizkor memorial prayers for the dead. Traditional prayers include Al Het, a list of sins whose initials form the Hebrew alphabet. As the worshiper recites the list, he strikes his chest to emphasize repentance.

Last service of the day is Neilah, signaling the closing of heaven’s gates and the sealing of everyone’s fate for another year.

Although non-Jews might view the High Holy Days as guilt-ridden, rabbis say the observance actually shows divine mercy. They point out that het, usually translated “sin,” is an archery term that means to miss the mark. And shuva, repentance, is almost identical to teshuva, to turn — as in returning to right living.

— James D. Davis

Written by Jim Davis

September 18, 2018 at 10:59 pm

Rosh Hashana signals New Year — and season of repentance

leave a comment »

Rosh Hashana, the Jewish new year, started at sundown Sunday, Sept. 9, for the world’s 14.5 million Jews. Rosh Hashana, starting the Hebrew year 5779, begins the solemn 10-day period known as the High Holy Days.

Also called Yamim Noraim, or Days of Awe, the holy days are a pause in time when the faithful fast and pray for pardon from their sins over the past year. Jewish tradition says God scrutinizes each person, waiting to see who is worthy of good or bad fortune for the next year.

Liberal Jews likewise use the High Holy Days as a time to review their lives and resolve to be better persons. Area synagogues often rent community auditoriums to handle the overflow of worshipers who seldom attend temple otherwise.

During the season, Jews wish one another L’Shanah Tovah Tikatevu, or “May you be inscribed for a good year.” Many also keep an edible tradition of apples dipped in honey, a tasty hope for a “sweet New Year.”

The High Holy Days end this year starting at sundown Sept. 18 with Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement. That day-long series of services ends with a final blast from the ram’s horn, closing God’s books and sealing everyone’s fate for the year.

— James D. Davis


Written by Jim Davis

September 10, 2018 at 3:28 am

Holiday Almanac: Jews celebrate holy law today

leave a comment »

Torah 02

Torah page, photographed by Renaude Hatsedakis, via freeimages.com.

Shavuot, the Festival of Weeks, began at sundown for the estimated half-million Jews in South Florida. Shavuot celebrates the giving of the law to Moses on Mount Sinai.

The holiday is one of the three Jewish ‘‘pilgrim festivals,” along with Passover and Sukkot, meant to recall the Israelites’ escape from slavery in Egypt and subsequent wanderings in the Sinai desert. Shavuot takes its name from Passover, which it follows by seven weeks — a ‘‘week of weeks.”

Synagogues observe Shavuot with the reading of the Ten Commandments. Some also read the biblical story of Ruth, who converted to Judaism and became the grandmother of King David. The story is seen as a historical parable of commitment to God and the holy law.

In recent years, many synagogues have increasingly held confirmation on Shavuot, as their young men and women take on the promise to obey the holy law.

 — James D. Davis

Written by Jim Davis

May 20, 2018 at 4:17 pm

Passover celebrates freedom to worship

with one comment

matzoh, alex ringer (2)

Stack of matzoh used in Passover; photo by Alex Ringer via Freeimages.com.

Passover, called the oldest festival of freedom, starts at sundown today for the world’s Jews. The eight-day holiday dates back some 34 centuries, recounting the deliverance of the people of Israel from slavery in Egypt.

As the story is told in the biblical book of Exodus, the pharaoh rejected the prophet Moses’ demand to release the people, bringing a wave of 10 supernatural plagues on the land. The Nile River turned to blood, disease struck humans and livestock, vermin multiplied, the sky rained hail mixed with fire, and darkness struck the land for three days.

The last plague was the Angel of Death, who struck down the firstborn of every Egyptian household in one night. The Israelites escaped death by dashing lambs’ blood on their doorposts — a sign of faith that made the angel “pass over” those homes.

In modern Jewish homes, Passover starts with a ceremonial meal called a Seder on the first two nights, with foods symbolizing the Exodus story. They include a lamb shank, for the sacrificial animal; a piece of bitter herbs such as horseradish, for the bitterness of slavery; a bowl of saltwater, for the tears of oppression; and a mix of apples, cinnamon and wine, for the mortar used in the Egyptian bricks.

Also on the Seder plate are a roasted egg and leafy vegetables, for the springtime occasion of Passover; and the hard, unleavened bread called matzoh, for the Israelites’ haste in evacuating Egypt.

— Jim Davis


Written by Jim Davis

March 30, 2018 at 7:00 pm

Holiday Almanac: Purim, the Jewish Festival of Lots, starts tonight

leave a comment »

Purim05Sundown today ushers in Purim, the joyous Jewish Festival of Lots that celebrates the deliverance of the Jews from a would-be mass murderer 2,500 years ago.

The story, told in the biblical book of Esther, takes place in Persia, where many of the Jews were living in exile. There Esther, a Jewish woman, won a beauty contest and married King Ahasuerus.

Haman, the king’s prime minister, hated the Jews after Esther’s cousin Mordecai refused to bow to him. Haman persuaded the king, who was unaware Esther was Jewish, to sign an iron-clad decree for the Jews’ extermination.

After Esther bravely pled her people’s case, Ahasuerus changed his mind but could not rescind the decree. However, he issued another order allowing the Jews to defend themselves. They killed thousands of their enemies, and Haman was hanged on the gallows he had built for Mordecai.

Purim takes its name from the Hebrew word for “lots,” for the method by which Haman had decided the date of the slaughter — which became, instead, the day of the great Jewish victory.

Boisterous celebrations lift Purim above its formal status as a minor religious holiday. Synagogues and Jewish community centers often sponsor Purim festivals, with carnival rides and games. Costume parties have children dressing as their favorite Purim characters. And refreshments include hamantaschen, triangular pastries in the traditional shape of Haman’s hat.


Written by Jim Davis

February 28, 2018 at 10:46 pm

%d bloggers like this: